DNA Evidence Not as Irrefutable as Made Out to Be

A woman's DNA matches that of a sample found at crime scene. The chances of a DNA match are just one in two million, so the woman must be guilty, right?

Wrong. But it's a common mistake to make, known as the prosecutor's fallacy. It mistakes the one in two million for the probability of the woman's innocence. In order to assess the woman's guilt properly, we need to take the fact that she matched the sample as a given, and see how much more likely this makes her to be guilty than she was before DA evidence came to light.

A version of Bays theorem, stated in terms of gambler's odds, is useful here. The matching probability above implies that the woman's DNA is two million times more likely to match the sample if she is guilty than if she is innocent. baye's theorem now says that:

Odds of guilt after DNA evidence = 2,000,000 x Odds of guilt before DNA evidence.

If our woman comes from a city of 500,000 people, and we think each of them is equally likely to have committed the crime, then her odds of guilt before the DNA evidence are about 1 in 500,000. Therefore:

Odds of guilt after DNA evidence = 2,000,000 x 1/500,000 = 4.

Translating into probabilities, this gives an 80% chance of guilt. Definitely not beyond reasonable doubt! There are recorded examples of the prosecutor's fallacy leading to wrongful convictions.

This is an excerpt from:

From Pythagoras' theorem and Einstein's relativity theory to Euclidean geometry and the butterfly effect-mathematics provides a whole new language with which we can recognize and describe the hidden patterns of our universe. Math Squared is a perfect introduction to the mysterious and magical world of numbers, taking you on a whistlestop tour from the essentials of arithmetic to the fascinating outer limits where mathematics and philosophy merge. With 10 topics across 10 chapters, each accompanied by explanatory illustrations, Math Squared is the ideal primer for those who want to learn more about the language of numbers. Click here for more information.