The Difference Between a Broadcast Domain and a Collision Domain
By Stephen Bucaro
One of the most confusing things to understand in computer networking is the difference
between a broadcast domain and a collision domain. Much of the confusion results because
of the operation of a network switch. So to understand where the broadcast domains and
collision domain exist within a network, it's easier if you focus on the network switches.
A switch is a multi-port device that, traditionally, operates at layer 2, the data link layer,
of the OSI model. Here packets are sent to a specific switch port based on its destination
MAC addresses. Any broadcast traffic on a switch will be forwarded out all ports, so a
network switch has no effect on a broadcast domain. However, each port on a switch
becomes its own collision domain. So a switch is used to break up a collision domain.
Part of the confusion is because this means that a switch can send broadcasts between
collision domains. But that doesn’t mean the switch is joining the collision domains, they're
still separate collision domains, all receiving the same broadcasts.
More confusion comes in because, using VLANs (Virtual LANs), a switch can be logically
segmented into multiple broadcast domains. So much for a switch not being able to break
up a broadcast domain.
Even more confusion comes in because routers operate at layer 3, the network layer,
of the OSI model. Routers do not forward broadcasts from one network to another network.
But a layer 3 switch is basically a switch that can perform routing in addition to switching,
so again we have a switch breaking up a broadcast domain.
And, to add even more confusion, a router can be configured to forward broadcasts from
one network to another network. So now, you can't even sat for sure that routers break
up broadcast domains.
And, let's not forget to consider the network bridge. To avoid further confusion, just think
of a bridge as a single port switch. A bridge operates at layer 2 and breaks up a collision
domain, but not a broadcast domain, similar to a switch, but with only one network boundary.
Hubs don't add to the confusion because they don't do anything. They're strictly a device
for connection convenience. Each port on a hub is in the same collision and broadcast domain.
Repeaters don't add to the confusion because all they do is clean up and amplify the
signal. They don't do anything to the collision or broadcast domain.
So if you're asked on an exam, remember the traditional definition is that a switch is a
layer 2 device that breaks up a collision domain, but not a broadcast domain. And the
traditional definition is that a router is a later 3 device that breaks up a broadcast domain,
and of course also a collision domain.
More Networking Topologies Articles:
• The IEEE 802.3 Ethernet Standards
• Understanding Optical Fiber Types
• System Area Network Interface Cards
• Distance Vector vs. Link State vs. Hybrid Routing
• What is FTTP, FTTH, FTTB, and FTTD?
• Wireless or Wired Network?
• Understanding Wireless LAN Networking
• Trunking, Bonding, Aggregation; What Does it Mean?
• Six Things You Must Know About Fiber Optic Cable Materials
• A Guide to Broadband Internet Connections